Garden Bloggers’ Design Workshop – Arbors and Pergolas Wrap-Up

Orchard arbor with ‘Red Noodle’ beans Sept 26 07The other day, I was reading an article in an old issue of Gardens Illustrated about garden design elements, and it made me realize that I’ve been misusing the terms arbor and pergola. I’d always thought of an arbor as a relatively simple structure that arched over a path or a bench and a pergola as a more extensive, roofed structure that provided shade for a walkway or sitting area. According to the article (“Elements of Garden Design: Structures” by Cleve West), however, an arbor is primarily a sitting area and serves as a focal point; a pergola covers a path and frames a focal point, and an arch is…well, an arch. So I suppose what I’ve been calling arbors in my garden are technically arches. Apparently, I’m not the only one that’s confused, though; now I notice that plenty of writers use the terms interchangeably. So, maybe it doesn’t really matter what you call your structures, as long as you like how they look.

Many of you have incorporated arches, arbors, pergolas, and similar structures in your own gardens and enjoy using them as supports for a wide variety of climbing plants. Below is an overview of posts we know about on this month’s topic, roughly arranged by subject. If you know of others, or if you write related posts of your own later on, add a comment below and we’ll include them in the main list. Thanks to all who read and participated! And please, let me know if any of these links don’t work, or if I missed any of you. (It’s getting tough keeping up with you all!)

Garden Bloggers’ Design Workshop – Arbors and Pergolas (Nan at Gardening Gone Wild): Initial post for this month’s topic.

Some Practical Considerations

The Year of Living Structurally (Mr. McGregor’s Daughter): The story of the wooden arbor in the woodland garden at Squirrelhaven. A Mighty Wind tells the tale of near-disaster with the same arbor. And in Garden Bloggers’ Design Workshop – Arbors and Pergolas, MMD asks for suggestions on providing a good foundation to protect her arbor from future gusts.

Building Patio and Pergola (Karen at Savannah Garden): A detailed step-by-step of the creation a beautiful backyard patio and pergola in Karen’s garden.

Our Garden Pergola is Complete (Stuart at Gardening Tips ‘n’ Ideas): Thinking about installing a pergola of your very own? Check out Stuart’s planning pointers before you build.

Selecting an Entry Arbor (Angela at Cottage Magpie): If you can’t decide on the perfect arbor for your garden, you’re not alone. It took Angela three tries, but even the not-so-perfect arbors are charming.

Design Inspiration

Arbors & Pergolas, Frank & Me (Jim at The Art of Gardening): Check out photos of arbors and trellises at Frank Lloyd Wright’s Taliesin, and in Jim’s own garden too.

Garden Walk Buffalo Arbors (Jim at the Art of Gardening): Lovely photos of some stunning arbors and pergolas from…you guessed it: Garden Walk Buffalo.

Arbors and Pergolas (Michelle at Garden Porn): Once again, Michelle treats us to some stunning shots of glorious garden structures. Hey, we can all dream, right?

Arbors & Pergolas – Garden Bloggers’ Design Workshop (Pam at Digging): A glorious gallery of traditional and not-so-traditional arches and arbors Pam has photographed on her travels.

Of Arbours and Pergolas (Jodi at Bloomingwriter): The story of several arbors (um…arbours) and the plants that adorn them in Jodi’s garden in Nova Scotia.

Arbours and Pergolas – Part 1 and Arbours and Pergolas – Part 2 (Shirl at Shirl’s Gardenwatch): Part 1 is a gallery of photos collected while Shirl was gathering design ideas; Part 2 shows some of the structures in her own garden. If you’re considering adding an arbor or pergola to your own garden, you can get some great ideas here!

Going Up (Nan at Gardening Gone Wild): Rustic wood arbors and metal arches in Nan’s current garden.

Arbors Revisited (Nan at Hayefield): Painted wood and copper-pipe arches in Nan’s previous garden, along with some of her favorite climbers.

Arbors in My Cutting Garden (Fran at Gardening Gone Wild): The evolution of several wooden arbors in Fran’s garden. Arbors in the Garden-Part 2 continues the story of other stunning structures.

Green Thumb Sunday – Fences and Arbors (Dee at Red Dirt Ramblings): Dee shares the story of some structures in her Oklahoma garden.

The Bower and More Bower and Pergola Chat (Lisa at Greenbow): In the first post, Lisa shows how she turned the trauma of a couple of dead trees into a gloriously shaded sitting area. In the second, she discusses the design and construction of a custom-made wooden arbor. To see her metal arch, check out Metal Arch Arbor.

The Transitory Rustic Garden Arch (Kathy at Cold Climate Gardening): Serendipity at its finest. Why build an arch when you’re lucky enough to have something like this happen?

For Something a Little Different

Garden Bloggers’ Design Workshop: Arbors, Pergolas (and the midnight bowling ball accident of 2003) (Craig at Ellis Hollow): You’ll laugh, you’ll cry…well, maybe not, but it’s still a great story of the rise and fall of some vertical structures in Craig’s garden.

Fairy Gazebo (Frances at Faire Garden): Hey, even fairies enjoy a little shade too, you know. If you’re considering treating yours to their own special space, or if you just enjoy a little garden whimsy, check it out!

Remembering Martin Luther King (Fran at Gardening Gone Wild): Do you know what a “hush arbor” is? If that term’s new to you, check out Fran’s story.

Vines and Climbers

GBDW Arbors and Pergolas – Killer – The Dilemma (Frances at Faire Garden): If you have limited space and are considering growing a climbing rose on an arbor or pergola, you may want to think twice about ‘Alberic Barbier’ (a.k.a. Killer). You can follow his saga in the follow-up posts Killer – An Update and Killer – The Final Chapter? I won’t tell you Killer’s ultimate fate here, but I can give you a clue: In Roses – The Vote, Frances investigates some nearly thornless roses for her garden.

Roses of Memory (Dee at Red Dirt Ramblings): Not all climbers are as rampant as Killer, as proved by Dee’s post of some beauties she treasures.

Sweet Autumn is Here (Carolyn Gail at Sweet Home and Garden Chicago): Need something flower-full and fragrant to dress up your fall garden? Sweet autumn clematis might be the climber for you.

Two Perfect Flowering Plants for Arbors (Heirloom Gardener): Roses and clematis – what could be more lovely for a romantic garden arbor?

Garden Bloggers’ Design Workshop: Adding Vertical Interest to the Garden (Robin at A Bumblebee Garden): Go drool over Robin’s wisteria-draped white arbor, and read about some other climbers and vertical accents in her garden.

About Nancy J. Ondra

Nan gardens on 4 acres in Bucks County, Pennsylvania. In the firm belief that every garden ought to have a pretentious-sounding (or at least pretentious-looking) name, she refers to her home grounds as "Hayefield." There, she experiments with a wide variety of plants and planting styles, from cottage gardens and color-based borders to managed meadows, naturalistic plantings, and veggies--all under the watchful eyes of her two pet alpacas, Daniel and Duncan.

If you enjoyed this article, get email updates (it's free).


, ,

12 Responses to Garden Bloggers’ Design Workshop – Arbors and Pergolas Wrap-Up

  1. Ellis Hollow January 31, 2008 at 7:24 am #

    Hi Nan:

    For some reason, in my own head the terms pergola and gazebo get interchanged. Perhaps that’s why you thought of the former as a sitting area? Thanks for organizing this and including a link to my bowling ball story..

    Craig

    Right, gazebo – that’s another one. I’m kind of glad this topic is about done! (And er…sorry about the error you pointed out; fixed now. Many thanks, Craig.)
    -Nan

  2. Frances January 31, 2008 at 7:25 am #

    What a great topic, Nan. Many had wonderful stories to share, and I’ll bet many more were inspired to build that arbor they have been spinning around in the back of their minds. What’s next?

    Frances at Faire Garden

    I promise you’ll know the new topic first thing tomorrow, Frances. But I’ll give you a hint now: You already have three posts that relate to the subject.
    -Nan

  3. Dee/reddirtramblings January 31, 2008 at 7:32 am #

    Hi Nan,

    Thanks for linking to my two posts about roses and arbors. The definitions put forth by Gardens Illustrated are really interesting. Who knew that an “arbor” was a place to sit? Well, at least one of mine follows the accurate definition. Thanks for the info.~~Dee

    Hi Dee! I found you through some comments you left on other posts and wanted to make sure you were included.
    -Nan

  4. Robin January 31, 2008 at 8:23 am #

    That’s interesting, I always thought arbors were arched or smaller structures through which you enter on a path, and pergolas were over sitting areas.

    I wish I could have participated in this design topic, but have neither in my garden. It was inspiring to read and see others pictures though.
    Thanks, Nan.

    I guess we’ll leave the definitions to the designers, Robin. We all seem to know what mean, anyway. Next month’s topic is much less complicated, and everyone should be able to participate in some way, if they wish.
    -Nan

  5. Lisa at Greenbow January 31, 2008 at 8:38 am #

    I loved this topic. It is wonderful to have all the posts together because I found several I had missed. Such great ideas everyone has. Vines…I need vines and ….

    …and bines, and lianas, and ramblers, and more! After the arbor/arch/pergola/bower/gazebo muddle, I’m a little relieved that no one addressed the technical differences among the climbers. Though maybe someone wants to take that on? In the meantime, yes, think vines!
    -Nan

  6. Dave January 31, 2008 at 9:50 am #

    That’s a good compilation of arbor/arches. I’ll have to go back and look at them all!

    Thanks, Dave! It was fun having a reason to read them all again. Enjoy!
    -Nan

  7. commonweeder January 31, 2008 at 1:19 pm #

    I’ve just discovered GGW through Kathy at Cold Climate Gardening and I’m eager to learn more about the GB Design Workshop. We have an arbor in front of our south facing house, over the ‘piazza’, or patio for those who don’t live in Heath, and it is finally covered with wisteria. I love the shade, and the way it changes the quality of light in the house. The arch we built out of piping is unlovely and I have yet to find a good climber for it, but I am ever hopeful.

    A hearty welcome to you, commonweeder! If you have the time to visit all the links above, you’ll likely have plenty of ideas for your arch by the time you’re done. Or post some pictures of said arch on your blog, leave us a note here, and we’ll all descend on you with suggestions of our own favorites!
    -Nan

  8. Rick Anderson January 31, 2008 at 4:26 pm #

    I’ve written a few about pergolas that get a bit of interest. These are all structures I’ve designed, and were built for clients.

    Pergola’s are generally larger structures, much larger than arbors.

    Those 2 post with a overhead that you walk through to go from one type of space to another-that’s a arbor, and I’m sticking to it.

    Thanks for visiting, Rick! Here’s a direct link to the pergola-tagged posts on your site, for those who’d like to visit.
    -Nan

  9. Heirloom Gardener February 2, 2008 at 1:26 pm #

    Nan,

    I loved reading all of the posts. I now want to add arbors and pergolas all over my garden–a new one for the Bird Garden, replace the one in the Children’s Garden, a new one for the Walled Garden…

    Thanks,

    Heirloom Gardener

    As you work through your to-do list, remember to take pictures, then leave a link back here when you post them!
    -Nan

  10. James | Double Danger April 16, 2008 at 11:22 am #

    We just recently decided to make a grape arbor and so we sketched it out and 3 hours later we were done. It was simple but creative and nice. Check it out if you get a chance.

    Grape Arbor

    It wasn’t much, but effective and unique.

    Unplanned projects can be great fun, and yours looks like a good one, James. Thanks for sharing!
    -Nan

  11. Dave May 3, 2009 at 12:28 pm #

    Hi Nan,

    Could you add my Arbor Project to your list? Thanks!

    Dave

    Thanks for the reminder, Dave. It’s certainly a beauty! (And yes, I’ve voted.)
    -Nan

  12. Dee/reddirtramblings January 16, 2010 at 6:30 pm #

    Thanks so much for including me in this auspicious, arbor-building and raising group. I’ve got some reading to do. I don’t know how you find all of us, but again, thank you.~~Dee